This is a belated posting about dealings I had back in March with the slowness of Net::SFTP even with Math::BigInt::GMP installed. In short, I successfully replaced Net::SFTP with Net::SFTP::Foreign in my scripts and am now enjoying native transfer rates.

Foreign uses the system’s ssh clients instead of a pure pure implementation
as Net::SFTP does. With Net::SFTP::Foreign I reduced a 1.2GB download from 4 hours to 20 minutes.

It also doesn’t have the 1GB ssh rekeying hang that an unpatched Net::SFTP has.

There is a Compat sub-module that allows Net::SFTP::Foreign to work as a drop in replacement to Net::SFTP. In version 0.90_15 I had to comment out line 85 of Compat.pm, dontsave => !defined($remote), to get it to work. I didn’t report this to the maintainer at the time (sorry). I now see that there have been over a dozen releases of Net:SFTP::Foreign since I investigated this and I don’t know if this modification is still necessary.

I recommend Net::SFTP::Foreign where speed is important and a native client is available. But before rushing out to adopt it, do know that it prefers SSH key authentication. It won’t take passwords without some hoop jumping as described in the perldoc.

Advertisements